What the county requirement actually covers
Which buildings are in scope, which are exempt, and what changes on January 1, 2027, according to the law the County Council passed.
Montgomery County’s gas ban is often described in a sentence, and the sentence is usually wrong in one direction or the other. Here is what the law the County Council passed actually does, what it leaves out, and what changes on January 1, 2027.
The law.
Bill 13-22, Comprehensive Building Decarbonization, passed the County Council unanimously on November 29, 2022, and took effect on March 13, 2023. It is the first law of its kind in Maryland. Its central instruction is to the County Executive: issue all-electric building standards for new construction by December 31, 2026. Those standards take effect on January 1, 2027, the same date as the District’s requirement.
What is covered.
New construction. That includes new homes, and it is the part of the law residents hear least about. A house built under the new standard must be built without natural gas: no gas furnace, no gas water heater, no gas range, no gas dryer.
The date the County’s all-electric standards for new construction take effect. The District’s requirement takes effect the same day.
What is exempt.
The law writes several categories out of the all-electric standard:
- Commercial kitchens. Restaurant cooking is excepted. The District did not make the same choice; see What an all-electric kitchen actually costs.
- Hospitals and other facilities that need emergency backup systems.
- Manufacturing, life sciences and crematories.
Schools and income-restricted housing are given more time to meet the standard rather than an exemption from it.
Put the two lists together and a pattern appears. Many commercial uses were given exceptions or extra time. The new single-family home and the new townhouse were not.
What is not covered.
Existing homes. As introduced, Bill 13-22 would have reached major renovations and additions as well. The Council’s Planning, Housing and Economic Development Committee removed both before the final vote, to allow more time to work out how the standard would apply to them, and the enacted law covers new construction. Unlike the District, whose requirement reaches substantial improvements to existing buildings, Montgomery County does not require a homeowner to remove a working gas furnace or range, and a kitchen renovation does not trigger a conversion. That distinction matters. Residents in AREA’s research this summer were clear that they would expect it to be kept, and that a move to the District’s approach would meet resistance.
What it costs, and who pays.
For a new home the requirement means an all-electric build and, for the family that buys it, life on the more expensive fuel. Electricity is 3.5 times more expensive than natural gas for the same household energy use; a household with gas saves about $1,030 a year and could save $12,000 over 15 years compared with a new all-electric home. Eight in ten homebuyers in the region want to be able to choose gas. Under the standard, buyers of new homes in the County will not have that choice.
What AREA is asking for.
Before the standard takes effect, an impact assessment of what it adds to the cost of a new home and to that home’s monthly bills, listening sessions with the residents and builders it covers, and a plan for the households it hits hardest. The County exempted the uses it judged could not reasonably comply. It owes homebuyers the same analysis. Join AREA.